The Divergent Faction Challenge: Week One (Abnegation)

So. A week of abnegation. (For those who wonder what the hell I’m talking about, check out my post from Tuesday, or go to Deb Driza’s site for more information.)
First of all, according to the Divergent fansite, this is what Veronica says about the Abnegation faction:
ABNEGATION:
2. to relinquish; give up
I like the verbs in that one: refuse, deny, reject, renounce–active forms of stripping things from your life. As opposed to relinquish, give up– more passive. (from Veronica Roths Site)
What Veronica says about Abnegation in Divergent
- Wear Grey Uniforms
- Known for Selflessness
- Grey clothes, plain hairstyle, and unassuming demeanor are supposed to make it easier for them to forget themselves
- Families move in harmony
- Houses are all made of Grey cement, few windows in economical no nonsense rectangles. Lawns are crabgrass and mailboxes are dull metal.
- Everything in Abnegation is meant to make them forget themselves and protect themselves and protect them from vanity, greed, and envy. If they have little and want for little and are equal, they envy no one.
- Fulfilled need for selfless leaders in government.

Okay, so that doesn’t exactly describe me. (Although I do have the crabgrass and dull metal mailbox…does that count?)
The first thing I realized in this exercise is that very little is totally selfless. I clean up the kitchen? It’s because I hate seeing the house so dirty. I offer to put the kids to bed so the Husband can work? I cherish the few minutes at the end of the night that they tell me about their days and hug me tight. I don’t put on any makeup and rush off to drop kids at school looking like death warmed over? Well, it’s too bad but I was in a rush and anyway, who really cares?
So what is truly selfless? Anything? And perhaps most importantly, does it matter?
I ultimately decided that results and outcomes matter more than motivation. After all, if you heart is pure and your motive honest but you wind up doing harm what the heck is the use? So I focused on outcomes…I tried hard to make Small Daughter and Large Son smile, to make the house a pleasant place to be, to say yes to people when I kind of wanted to say no. And that felt pretty good. So maybe denying oneself isn’t really the name of the game…I wonder what Tris would say…
(Better read Divergent and see!)

8 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 13, 2011 at 2:27 pm
Debra D.
Yes, it looks like several of us struggled with the exact same thing you did—what exactly does it mean to be selfless?
(that poster was hilarious, btw)
So glad you played–I linked your post in mine!
May 13, 2011 at 4:44 pm
Jennifer
I love that pic, absolutely!! And I’m so glad others struggled as much as I did. Definitely not selfless with that thought
May 13, 2011 at 5:06 pm
Houndrat.com » Blog Archive » Divergent Challenge Week One: Abnegation Fail
[...] Dana Alison Levy [...]
May 13, 2011 at 8:32 pm
Kaitlin
That pic is hilarious! And I like the idea that the outcome matters more than the motivation. I think it’s true, and I bet it’s true for the characters even in the book–especially the young ones like Tris who aren’t sure they really feel quite selfless at heart.
May 13, 2011 at 9:13 pm
Sarah
It sounds like you totally got the benefit of Agnegation! You have the absolute right attitude about it—being as dedicated to all the Abnegation rules as the Faction is in the book is a recipe for… madness.
May 13, 2011 at 11:16 pm
Ka.thy Br.adey
I love the poster!
Good call about the outcome mattering more than the motivation
May 14, 2011 at 12:49 pm
Jamie Blair
Lots of us had the same thoughts on this one. Is it selfless if you get something out of it? Does it have to hurt to be selfless? I don’t know…
May 17, 2011 at 9:59 am
Sarah Nicolas
It seems like a lot of us came to the same conclusions last week. Well said!